The end of 2019 saw the emergence of a new human coronavirus (COVID-19) spread rapidly around the world and has a high degree of lethality. In more severe cases, patients remain in hospital inpatient units, under the care of the health team. To serve this population, it is important to use and develop potential tools to meet the demands of physical activity and improve cardiorespiratory fitness. In this sense, exposure therapies of virtual reality are promising and, although limited for this purpose, have been shown to be an adequate and equivalent alternative to traditional exercise programs. Fifty patients with confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 will be evaluated in an inpatient unit at Hospital São Paulo, at Escola Paulista de Medicina, Universidade Federal de São Paulo (HSP - EPM/UNIFESP). After completing all the questionnaires and tests of the initial evaluation (Medical Research Council Scale, Visual Analogue Scale, BORG Scale, Brunel's Mood Scale, Satisfaction Scale and Heart Rate Variability - HRV), the individuals will be divided into two groups being Group A: Subjects with COVID-19 who will start the first day of the protocol with Virtual Reality tasks in the morning and then in the second period, in the afternoon, will perform the conventional exercises (n = 25); And Group B: Subjects with COVID-19 who will start the first day with conventional exercises in the morning and in the second period, in the afternoon, will perform activity with virtual reality (n = 25). After the application of therapies, final evaluations will be carried out. The rehabilitation protocol will be applied during all days of hospitalization. For the protocol, the Heart Rate Variability indices will be evaluated in three moments: (1) rest before the task, (2) during the intervention, (3) recovering from the intervention. The performance data during the activity in Virtual reality will also be evaluated. The results of this study will assist in assessing the response to rehabilitation therapies during hospitalization and the prognosis of these patients.
To carry out this study, an experimental protocol will be used, where patients admitted to an
inpatient unit of the São Paulo hospital will perform a rehabilitation protocol at two
different times using virtual reality tasks and conventional therapies.
In the first moment, in the initial evaluation, only on the first day of care with the
patient, the Medical Research Council Scale, Visual Analog Scale, BORG Scale, Brunel Mood
Scale and Satisfaction Scale will be applied. At the end of the therapy, a BORG scale is
applied to assess and monitor the patient's perception of effort. For the evaluation and
characterization of the sample will be used:
Medical Research Council scale (MRC)
The Medical Research Council (MRC) was created in 1943, it is an instrument adapted to assess
muscle strength in critically ill patients. The result is obtained through the evaluation of
six movements of upper limbs (upper limbs) and lower limbs (lower limbs) and the strength is
graded between 0 (plegia) to 5 points (normal strength). The maximum sum can reach 60 points,
values below 48 are considered that the patient has muscle weakness.
Visual Analog Scale (EVA) The visual analog scale (VAS) is an instrument to assess the degree
of pain in the patient, it consists of a 10 cm line that has, in general, the phrases
"absence of pain and unbearable pain" as extremes.
Borg scale
The Borg scale is a tool for monitoring the intensity of physical effort, it is considered as
one of the most used instruments for the evaluation and quantification of the sensations of
physical effort, also known as subjective perception of effort (PSE). This is used both in
the area of high performance sports and in the area of physical rehabilitation, to monitor
the changes caused by physical exercise in the cardiorespiratory, metabolic, neuromuscular
systems.
Satisfaction Scale (EVA-S)
The 10 cm Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) assesses the level of satisfaction of the interviewed
individuals. Patients will answer the questionnaire, and they will be asked to mark with a
vertical line at the scale location that indicates satisfaction with rehabilitation, in which
zero (0) indicates very dissatisfied and 10 indicates very satisfied.
This scale was developed to allow a quick measurement of the mood of adults and adolescents.
BRUMS contains 24 simple mood indicators, such as feelings of anger, disposition, nervousness
and dissatisfaction that are noticeable by the individual being assessed. The evaluated
responds the scale according to how they feel about such sensations.
The score is 5 points (0 = nothing to 4 = extremely). The form put in the question is "How do
you feel now", although other forms: "How have you felt this past week, including today", or
"How do you normally feel" can be used. BRUMS takes about one to two minutes to respond.
The 24 indicators on the scale comprise six subscales: anger, confusion, depression, fatigue,
tension and vigor.
Respiratory Rate (RR)
Respiratory rate (RR) is defined as the number of breaths a person takes 1 minute (breaths /
min), being an important vital sign. It varies in response to metabolic demand and the normal
range for an adult is 12 to 20 breaths.
Before starting therapy with VR and conventional therapy, RF will be measured. At the end of
the respective therapies, the RF will be checked again.
Heart Rate (HR)
All heart rate records will be performed using a cardiofrequency meter (V800, Polar). After
placing the brace and monitor, individuals will be placed in supine position and will remain
at rest breathing spontaneously for 15 minutes and then for another 10 minutes during
interventions, whether during VR or conventional.
Oxygen Saturation (Spo2)
Pulse oximetry is widely used for patients who need continuous monitoring of oxygen
saturation. Its main purpose is the early detection of hypoxemia in various situations and
the monitoring of perfusion and circulation. It is a non-invasive monitoring.
Heart Rate Variability (HRV)
HRV is a simple, reliable, inexpensive and non-invasive measure to capture autonomic
impulses. The widespread use and cost-effectiveness of the technique and the ease of data
acquisition make HRV a capable choice for the interpretation of cardiac autonomic functioning
and a promising clinical tool to assess and identify physiological changes. Fluctuations in
HRV patterns provide an early and sensitive diagnosis of the human body's physiological
behavior and the individual's health status.
HRV has emerged as a simple and non-invasive measure of autonomic impulses, representing one
of the most promising quantitative markers of autonomic balance. HRV describes oscillations
in the interval between consecutive heartbeats (R-R intervals), as well as oscillations
between consecutive instantaneous heart rates. It is a measure that can be used to assess the
modulation of the ANS under physiological conditions, such as in waking and sleeping
situations, different body positions, physical training, and also in pathological conditions.
Changes in HRV patterns provide a sensitive and early indicator of health impairments
Virtual Reality Training
Participants will perform the tasks individually in a room equipped with a computer, table
and chair, in the presence of the evaluator responsible for providing the instructions and
recording the results. The chair and footrest will be adjusted according to the individual's
height and needs, so that they are positioned correctly during the task. Participants will be
instructed to sit in a way they think is most comfortable.
Before starting the task, the researcher will explain the task verbally and will demonstrate
how the game works. Then, participants will complete a one-time trial in order to verify that
they understand the instructions.
Intervention After performing all the tests and questionnaires of the initial evaluation,
individuals will be divided into two groups, being Group A: Subjects with COVID -19 who will
start the first day of the protocol with Virtual Reality tasks in the morning and then in the
second period in the afternoon, they will perform conventional exercises (n = 25); And Group
B: Subjects with COVID -19 who will start the first day with conventional exercises in the
morning and in the second period, in the afternoon, will perform activity with virtual
reality (n = 25). After the application of therapies, final evaluations will be carried out.
The rehabilitation protocol will be applied during hospitalization.
Participants will perform the virtual tasks individually in a room equipped with a computer,
table and chair, in the presence of the evaluator responsible for providing the instructions
and recording the results. The chair and footrest will be adjusted according to the
individual's height and needs, so that they are positioned correctly during the task.
Participants will be instructed to sit in a way they think is most comfortable.
Before starting the task, the researcher will explain clearly and objectively how the game
works. Then, participants will complete a one-time attempt to make sure they understand the
instructions.
MoveHero
Software developed at the School of Arts, Sciences and Humanities of the University of São
Paulo will be used. The game features balls that fall, in four imaginary columns on the
computer screen, to the rhythm of the chosen music. The task is not to let the balls fall.
However, the balls can only be touched when they reach four circles placed in parallel (at
two height levels), two on the left and two on the right of the participant (0 0 \ o / 0 0),
called targets 1, 2 , 3 and 4, as viewed from left to right.
The game captures the participant's movements through a webcam, not requiring physical
contact to perform the task, so the participant must move his arms, at a distance of one and
a half meters from the computer screen. The participant must wait for the balls to fall,
until they begin to overlap one of the target circles. Therefore, the game requires the
participant to have a strategy of anticipating the movement to reach the balls within those
circles.
The game offers hit feedback through a numbering (+1) that appears next to the sphere that
has been successfully hit within the target, in addition, the total score is visible in the
upper left corner of the screen, with 10 points for each hit.
Conventional task
Participants will perform the tasks individually in the inpatient sector, in the presence of
the evaluator responsible for providing instructions and recording the results.
Statistical analysis Statistical analyzes will be performed using IBM-SPSS (version 26.0, IBM
Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). As dependent variables, all HRV indices will be considered. If the
data meet the assumptions of normality, Multiple Analysis of Variances (MANOVA) will be used
to compare the study groups (Virtual Group and Conventional Group) and intra-group comparison
(virtual and conventional group, when comparing the same subject), with Minimum Significant
Difference (LSD) post-test. If the data do not meet the assumptions of normality, the
differences between the groups will be analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. Dunn's post
hoc tests will be performed on each pair of groups, with Dunn-Bonferroni post-test on each
pair of groups66. Values of p <0.05 will be considered significant.
Device: Virtual reality therapy first
First day of the protocol with Virtual Reality intervention in the morning and conventional intervention in the afternoon
Device: Conventional therapy first
First day of the protocol with conventional intervention in the morning and Virtual Reality intervention in the afternoon
Inclusion Criteria:
- Inpatients with confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Cardiac arrhythmias and atrioventricular block,
- Congenital anomalies, such as congenital heart disease,
- Pulmonary malformations,
- Drugs that interfere with SNA, such as anti-arrhythmic drugs.
Comitê de Ética da Universidade Federal
São Paulo, Brazil
Talita D da Silva, Ph.D., Principal Investigator
Universidade Federal de São Paulo