The 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-2019) pandemic is an enormous health issue of worldwide scale. Prevention and/or treatment with a widely-available and already-licensed product such as vitamin D (cholecalciferol) could have a large impact on healthcare worldwide. Given ethnic variation in vitamin D production, this could help to address the discrepancies in how people of different ethnicities are affected by COVID-19. There are currently no published studies analysing either individual-level evidence on the effect of vitamin D status on COVID-19 outcomes, or any prospective studies planning on following-up patients with reference to vitamin D and COVID-19 infection. The study will have 2 arms. Arm 1 will recruit patients hospitalised with COVID-19. Vitamin D levels will be measured in these patients and compared with outcome measures of COVID-19 severity. In Arm 2, patients will be recruited prospectively from local general practices (GPs) with measurement of vitamin D levels at enrolment. They will be followed up after 6 months to determine whether baseline vitamin D levels correspond with developing COVID-19. Data will be collected from a mixture of patient medical records, electronic patient records, laboratory data and from patients themselves. Data in Arm 1 will be analysed with a combination of linear and logistic regression, as appropriate, and with adjustment for covariates. Data in Arm 2 will be analysed as a case-control study, with adjustment for covariates. The primary objectives are to determine whether vitamin D levels affect outcomes in COVID-19 infection and whether vitamin D deficiency is associated with increased risk.
STUDY DESIGN Arm 1: Hospital in-patients with a clinical diagnosis of COVID-19 This will be
an observational cohort study of patients hospitalised at Tameside General Hospital with a
clinical diagnosis of COVID-19, as defined by the clinical coding department. Patient
identifiers will be extracted by the coding department and held on a secure server at
Tameside Hospital. Identifiers will be used to ensure serum samples already taken as part of
routine clinical management of these patients can be processed for a vitamin D level. No
additional blood samples will need to be taken.
Patient demographic details will be extracted from their clinical notes and electronic
patient records, then placed on an anonymised database for analysis. Data will be analysed to
determine the following:
1. Are vitamin D levels associated with outcomes/prognosis in patients hospitalised with
COVID-19?
2. Are vitamin D levels associated with ethnicity in patients hospitalised with COVID-19?
3. Are vitamin D levels associated with comorbidity in patients hospitalised with COVID-19?
Projected recruitment is 200 patients to be opportunistically recruited who are undergoing
usual clinical care for COVID-19.
Arm 2: Primary care patients prospectively studied with reference to baseline vitamin D and
risk of COVID-19 Patients will be prospectively recruited from local GP surgeries within the
Tameside and Glossop Clinical Commissioning Group. Patients will be consented by Good
Clinical Practice (GCP)-certified practitioners. A serum sample will be collected on
recruitment for a baseline vitamin D level to be obtained. Patient contact details will be
collected, as well as baseline health status and comorbidities, then stored on an encrypted
database on a secure server at Tameside Hospital. Vitamin D levels will be communicated to GP
surgeries and GPs can decide whether to treat patients according to local treatment
guidelines for suboptimal vitamin D. After 6 months, patients will be followed-up via
telephone interview, in order to ascertain whether they have developed COVID-19, any
treatment outcomes for this, and whether they have been treated with vitamin D in the interim
in primary/secondary/tertiary care.
Data will be analysed once all recruited patients have been followed-up after 6 months. At
follow-up, patients who have developed COVID-19 will be deemed to be cases, and those who
have not will be deemed to be controls, for a case-control analysis using vitamin D levels as
an exploratory covariate. It is anticipated that there will be some patient drop-out, but
compliance with follow-up is likely to be high, due to the use of a telephone interview.
Analysis will aim to determine whether vitamin D levels are associated with the risk of
developing COVID-19, with reference to additional covariates, such as ethnicity and
comorbidity.
Projected recruitment is 800 patients to be opportunistically recruited who are attending
their GP surgery for routine care, not necessarily related to COVID-19.
INCLUSION CRITERIA Arm 1
Inclusion criteria:
- Aged >=18 years.
- Inpatient admitted to Tameside General Hospital.
- Clinical diagnosis of COVID-19 - not necessary for SARS-CoV-2 swab to be positive.
- Patients on vitamin D treatment to be included, but this will be adjusted for in
analysis.
Exclusion criteria:
- Aged <18 years.
- Final clinical diagnosis NOT COVID-19.
Arm 2
Inclusion criteria:
- Aged >=18 years.
- Patients on vitamin D treatment to be included, but this will be adjusted for in
analysis.
Exclusion criteria:
- Aged <18 years.
- On active treatment for malignancy/diagnosis of cancer within 6 months prior to
enrolment.
- Patients on immunosuppression.
ANALYSIS Arm 1
Mean values of age and gender, as well as proportions of different ethnic groups, will be
used to assess group comparability. Primary analysis will involve linear regression of
vitamin D levels (as a continuous variable, with adjustment for age and gender) against
variables representing COVID-19 treatment outcomes:
- Mode of oxygen therapy (low-flow <10L/min, high-flow>=10L/min, nasal high-flow, CPAP,
endotracheal intubation).
- Treatment history (excluding oxygen therapy).
- Discharge.
- Death.
Primary analysis will also include logistic regression of ethnic groups against the above
treatment outcome variables, with adjustment for age, gender and vitamin D status.
The following variables will be included as additional predictors of severity:
- Admission SpO2.
- Chest x-ray findings on admission.
- CRP on admission.
- D-dimer on admission.
- Creatinine on admission.
- Adjusted calcium on admission.
- Treatment with vitamin D.
- Ethnicity.
The following variables will be included as covariates:
- Age.
- Gender.
- Comorbidities.
- BMI.
- Presence of diabetes.
- SARS-CoV-2 swab result.
Linear regression will be reported as a coefficient with a 95% confidence interval. Logistic
regression will be reported as an adjusted odds ratio with a 95% confidence interval. Missing
data will be imputed. Analysis will be carried out once all data has been collected for n=200
patients and serum vitamin D levels are available.
Arm 2
Mean values of age and gender, as well as proportions of different ethnic groups, will be
used to assess group comparability. Once all data has been collected, patients who developed
COVID-19 will be defined as "cases" and those who did not will be defined as "controls." A
case-control study including vitamin D as a predictor variable will then be carried out, with
statistics reported as an adjusted odds ratio with a 95% confidence interval. Further
subanalysis will be carried out on the following outcome measures (again, being defined as a
"case"):
- Hospitalisation with COVID-19.
- Discharge from hospital following treatment for COVID-19.
- Death from COVID-19.
The following variables will be included as additional predictors of severity:
- Treatment with vitamin D.
- Ethnicity.
The following variables will be included as covariates:
- Age.
- Gender.
- Comorbidities.
- BMI.
- Presence of diabetes.
Missing data at enrolment will be imputed. Patients lost to follow-up will have baseline data
included and they will be treated as a "control." Analysis will be carried out once all
follow-up data has been collected for n=800 patients recruited.
ARM 1 - hospital in-patients
Inclusion Criteria:
- In-patient admitted to Tameside General Hospital.
- Clinical diagnosis of COVID-19 - not necessary for SARS-CoV-2 swab to be positive.
- Patients on vitamin D treatment to be included, but this will be adjusted for in
analysis.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Final clinical diagnosis NOT COVID-19.
ARM 2 - prospective primary care case-control study
Inclusion Criteria:
- Patients on vitamin D treatment to be included, but this will be adjusted for in
analysis.
Exclusion Criteria:
- On active treatment for malignancy/diagnosis of cancer within 6 months prior to
enrolment.
- Patients on immunosuppression e.g. for autoimmune disease, for solid organ transplant.
Tameside Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
Ashton-under-Lyne, Greater Manchester, United Kingdom
Margaret Cooper, Study Director
Tameside and Glossop Integrated Care NHS Foundation Trust