Official Title
A Pragmatic Superiority Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Brief Cognitive Behavioral Telepsychotherapy, Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy and Telepsychoeducation for the Reduction of Emotional Distress During COVID-19 Outbreak in Professionals and Students From Essential Services With a High Level of Emotional Distress in Brazil in the Context of COVID-19
Brief Summary

The study consists in a pragmatic superiority randomized controlled trial comparing different strategies of psychotherapy for professionals and students from essential services with high levels of emotional distress during the COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil. Therapeutic strategies to be evaluated are Brief Cognitive Behavioral Telepsychotherapy, Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy and Telepsychoeducation, as an active control. Note: This study was approved by the Ethics and Research Committee of the Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre and is originally registered at Plataforma Brasil, a Brazilian study registration platform (under CAAE: 30608420.5.0000.5327). Recruitment began in May 28th 2020.

Detailed Description

PRAGMATIC TREATMENT TRIAL

TITLE: "A pragmatic superiority randomized controlled trial comparing Brief Cognitive
Behavioral Telepsychotherapy, Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy and Telepsychoeducation
for the reduction of emotional distress during COVID-19 outbreak in professionals and
students from essential services with a high level of emotional distress in Brazil".

IMPORTANCE: COVID-19 outbreak is associated with increased emotional distress (depression,
anxiety, and irritability) all over the world. Currently, there are no large randomized
trials testing interventions to reduce the burden caused by mental disorders during a
pandemic outbreak of these proportions.

OBJECTIVE: To test the effectiveness of two modalities of Brief-Telepsychotherapy (Cognitive
Behavioral and Interpersonal) to the reduction of symptoms of emotional distress (anxiety,
depression, and irritability) in professionals and students from essential services with a
high level of those symptoms in Brazil during the COVID-19 outbreak.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS Thee-arm randomized clinical trial. Participants were
recruited in Brazil from the national service of telehealth provided by the ministry of
health. Participants included professional and students from essential services suffering
from high levels of anxiety, depression, and irritability symptoms during the COVID-19
outbreak. High levels of symptoms were defined by either of the following: (1) T score higher
than 70 on the PROMIS Anxiety Scale; (2) T score higher than 70 on the PROMIS Depression
Scale; (3) T score higher than 70 on the PROMIS Anger Scale.

INTERVENTIONS: All participants will be randomized 1:1:1: to the Cognitive Behavioral
Brief-Telepsychotherapy group (B-CBT, four sessions), Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy
(B-IPT, four sessions) or Telepsychoeducation group (a single session psychoeducation group
plus weekly personalized pre-recorded videos for 4 weeks).

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome will be the proportion of participants with a
50% reduction in T-scores in all the scales that were scored above 70 at baseline at 1-month.
Secondary outcomes (1) the same measure of the primary outcome but measured at 3-month and
6-months follow-up; (2) mean score change in individual scales, quality of life and remission
levels (proportion of patients with T-score of 50 or below in all of the four emotional
distress subscales); (3) the same measure of the primary outcome but measured at midpoint
(after the second session or 2-weeks); and (4) service satisfaction and net-promoter score at
the end of the treatment.

EXPECTED RESULTS: To detect a 15% group difference between each group, an alpha of 0.017 (3
comparisons, 0,05/3), power of 90%, and 20% loss to follow up, we would need a total of 333
participants per group.

Unknown status
Mental Disorder
COVID
Emotional Distress
Depression
Anxiety
Irritable Mood

Behavioral: Cognitive Behavioral Brief-Telepsychotherapy

Four sections of Cognitive Behavioral Brief-Telepsychotherapy plus personalized pre-recorded videos

Behavioral: Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy

Four sections of Brief Interpersonal Telepsychotherapy plus personalized pre-recorded videos

Behavioral: Telepsychoeducation

A single session psychoeducation group plus weekly personalized pre-recorded videos for 4 weeks

Eligibility Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

Professionals and students from essential services suffering from high levels of emotional
distress

- T score higher than 70 on the PROMIS Anxiety Scale

- T score higher than 70 on the PROMIS Depression Scale

- T score higher than 70 on the PROMIS Anger Scale

Exclusion Criteria:

- Moderate to severe suicide risk assessed by a psychiatrist

Eligibility Gender
All
Eligibility Age
Minimum: N/A ~ Maximum: N/A
Countries
Brazil
Locations

Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre
Porto Alegre, Rio Grande Do Sul, Brazil

Giovanni Salum, MD, PhD, Principal Investigator
Hospital de Clínicas de Porto Alegre, Porto Alegre/Brazil

Hospital de Clinicas de Porto Alegre
NCT Number
MeSH Terms
Mental Disorders